*Series premise explained and Snow White examined in the first part: Lessons from a Fantasy Princess: Snow White*
The Plot

A self-hating fish-woman craves the excitement, material splendor, and external genitalia of the surface world. Upon discovering a ship full of humans, she spies on them, becomes obsessed with a prince, and trades her voice to Ursula the Sea Witch for three days worth of legs. To make the change permanent she needs to obtain the true kiss of love or her deed of ownership will be transferred from Prince Eric back unto Ursula.
Ursula manages to leverage this initial bargain to guilt the king into giving up his magic trident, dignity, and status as a vertebrate. General mayhem ensues, and then Prince Eric drives his manly harpoon into the Seahag’s rear. Ariel’s voice is snatched back, more mayhem, and Prince Eric takes control of the situation by ramming the jagged prow of his busted ship straight though Ursula’s backless dress.
The king returns to form and retrieves his trident, and so moved is he by the power of Eric’s thrusting he not only accepts him as a son-in-law, he also magically changes his teenage daughter’s species — forever — so she can marry a dude she’s known for a week. The end.
A fair reading of the subtext
If a sixteen year old becomes discontent with her privileged life, it is perfectly reasonable to risk the destruction and enslavement of her entire culture to monkey bar herself from a controlling royal father figure onto an unknown handsome surrogate living in a desirable foreign locale. Should one need to make bargains with dark forces to achieve this don’t worry about the inevitable fallout, or actually keeping your word, strong men will eventually thrust your troubles into submission and return your voice to you at their earliest convenience.
–
Lessons inherent to the story
- If you keep doubling down on an flawed first impulse eventually karma will take over and lend a happy outcome to a series of self destructive choices. While impulsiveness and stupidity do sow turmoil and woe, there is no problem so great that a good man can’t gouge his way out of it with a busted table leg if properly motivated.
- Before deciding if a man is worthy of your heart and life-long fidelity, you must have the following information:
Are they passably handsome?
Do they have a dog that they occasionally play with?
Can they wear two boots, at the same time, without undue discomfort?
Once the preceding have been answered to an acceptable degree, feel free to abandon your family, culture, species, and justifiable unease with the dark arts to facilitate a second chance encounter with said gentleman.
- Should you choose to marry outside your species, the spiraling consequences will eventually lead to the collapse of your culture and enslavement of your father. So ladies, make sure you can pass fully or the stains of the past will dim the luster of your bright future. Remember, bitches hate fishes that switches for riches…so be sure to have a ready back story about growing up at some eccentric Oceanside boarding school.
Addendum
–If you are a moron hang out with bait fish and seagulls, you will feel smarter in comparison.
Lessons that I hope my daughter will extract
If you feel compelled to swap your voice for legs in a poorly negotiated dark bargain with the evilest person in town, go ahead.
If you are honestly that stupid you probably had little worth saying in the first place. But when seller’s remorse sets in don’t expect me to give up my magical powers to bail you out; I have seven other singing daughters, I’ll be fine. If that upsets you, take up interpretive dance and choreograph a slanderous ballet about what a terrible father I am.
- If a dude lack the stones to make a move, despite a choir of sea creatures[1] with orchestral accompaniment urging him on, he’s either impotent or a low jacked sex offender terrified of slipping up again. Cut your losses. Best case scenario he’s the straight-talking gay friend you clearly need, although you could just listen to the sassy crab version you’ve had all long.
- If you are a 16 year old mermaid suffering from first crush angst, and demanding to have your species magically changed so you can ditch town for an ill-conceived marriage in the human world, don’t be surprised if I suddenly can’t find my Trident. I am not your fairy godmother, I’m your father. If you want legs, earn them. Get a job, do some charity work with underprivileged sun fish, strike up a friendship with someone with opposable thumbs. Actually live in the world that you are so dismissive of.
If you still want to abandon your culture and live in the human world, once that desire is rooted in empathy and perspective, I’ll give you three legs and a going away party. If your burning love cannot bear such prudence… feel free to live in the bathtub in your beloved’s guest house, but you need to understand that change without cost is performance, not growth, and I will not be a party to it.
[1]Given those were ocean going creatures in a freshwater river they almost certainly died as soon as that musical number was over.
*Series premise explained and Snow White examined in the first part: Lessons from a Fantasy Princess: Snow White*
Series concluded In Lesson from a Fantasy Princess: Sleeping Beauty









FYI, your links back to the Snow White post are broken.
LikeLike
Ben: You took the time to read it and proof my shoddy linkmanship. 50 fine gentleman points to you sir. Much Obliged.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This is some of the funniest analysis of Disney princesses I’ve ever read. Please please do more, these are amazing. (Request: Belle!)
LikeLike
Thank you Kindly, Nicholas. Belle is tricky as she qualifies for the Disney princess standard (ie.female protagonist) but is actually a working class gall thrust into a bad situation. Also my deep allegiance to Gaston due to his prodigious spitting and overall competence makes objectivity difficult. I will consider it, though.
LikeLike
Belle is the ultimate anti-moral in the way her story exemplifies Stockholm Syndrome: it doesn’t matter if the you’re rude, or ugly, or downright abusive — if you’re rich enough, just hold the girl captive long enough and eventually she’ll fall in love with you, expecting you to change. Listen up girls: he won’t.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I get that it’s supposed to be “funny”, however all of your reading of subtexts is utter shit. It is a huge stretch by any imagination.
Also, what would a young girl learn from your writing? How to be crude, crass, sexist, elitist, self-important?
These are stories hundreds of years old re mastered, not modernized, if you can’t figure that out, you’re a fucking moron.
LikeLike
Look, I’m not arguing my elitism, lack of civility, smugness, sexist tendencies, racist tendencies, low intellect, or my whereabouts the night of June 15th 2007…I’ve earned whatever I have coming my way. But I didn’t spend five years studying at the Cordon Blue to have my understanding of subtext questioned. Now text, absolutely fair game, most plots are complete mysteries to me and I’m just this side of literate, but Subtexts….I have a gift and I’ll thank you honor it with your words and deeds.
Good Day to you, Sir.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I studied literature for my BA in college, and I think your comedic interpretations are awesome! It’s true those stories are hundreds of years old, but some of them were also written to have bad endings to teach lessons, such as the Little Mermaid- in the original, she dies and the prince marries another true human princess. Not exactly Disney material, so they changed it for the “Happily Ever After.” I loved Ariel and Bell, and Sleeping Beauty as a kid because they were beautiful and musically inclined, and because there were appealing action scenes (Can’t beat an epic Dragon Battle). It’s a good thing that more recent Disney movies are encouraging stronger and more independent female roles a little at a time, and showing their flaws (i.e. Anna from *Frozen* on true love with strangers).
Keep doing awesome work! It’s very entertaining and true.
LikeLiked by 2 people
I really enjoyed Pixars Brave, there was depth and ferocity to the lead that played the opposite of the historical princess type.
Thank you for the kind words and taking the time to read it.
LikeLike
I completely forgot about the real ending! My parents bought the original stories when I was young. And I actually liked them a little more. (Dont know why ) Thank you for reminding me!
LikeLike
just awesome… that’s all I have to say, oh, and thanks for making me laugh!
LikeLike
You are quite welcome.
LikeLike
I agree………what lessons are we giving our girls by making them watch this?
LikeLike
As long the parent is providing context and alternate fair It’s not too bad. But a steady diet of princess idealization can send us odd places.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It is not the puppy love that makes me angry……. it is the airbrushing of all the consequences and the resultant growing up of the human or half humans involved which has been poofed away by Disney…..
I want a Grimm version of the tale to show these kids that will make them cringe and think
LikeLike
You have a good point. Im not sure I enjoy cringing though…just the thinking.
LikeLike
Touche…
LikeLike
I’m sure once Airel got an extended look at the horrors of 14th century Europe the full weight of her choice would settle upon her. Plauge sores and constant warfare are a poor substitute for a hot crustacean band.
LikeLike
Well put, my friend.
LikeLike
Totally brightened my day to read this!
LikeLike
This is happy news.
LikeLike
Imagine an old French maiden marring a Viking. The Gaul of it all. Adieu crepe pancakes and get ready for the sea voyage.
LikeLike
I actually loved Ariel, until Princess Jasmine, and then Simba. But I was 5. As an adult I got a good giggle out of this! Totally never got the racist subtext!
Though I am now a little bit worried that I may have taken away one of the lessons inherent to the story ‘there is no problem so great that a good man can’t gouge his way out of it with a busted table leg if properly motivated.’ I think I can count at least one relationship that was never going to work which ended with me berating a man for ‘not making enough effort…’ I really hope you’re wrong about that one but I like know all the words to all the songs…oops!
LikeLike
I still randomly sing the Gaston song from Beauty and The Beast. I might have some broader sociological issues with the themes, but I can still appreciate the artistry of the performance.
LikeLike
Well played, sir. I commend you and agree wholeheartedly.
LikeLike
A friend of mine wrote an article for teaching magazine ‘Tes’ about how fairy tales set children up to have incorrect gender expectations. Judging by your post, I believe you may find it an interesting read. Link below.
http://www.tes.co.uk/article.aspx?storycode=6428971
LikeLike
This is awesome. The funniest thing to me is that take out the curse words and my parents more or less told me the same thing as a kid when I first watched this movie.
LikeLike
Sadly I often forget the “taking the curse words out” part when I discuss such things with my niece. I try, but colorful swearing is a part of the Ottawa Valley accent to an inescapable degree. Your parents sound like lovely people.
LikeLike
They are very lovely people. As I’ve grown up, I’ve realized how far ahead of their times they are and how much I’ve benefited from that.
LikeLike
On a completely side note I collected the stickers for this movie as a tiny child. It was fun. But on a grown up note. Its interesting what we can dig if we think about these stories that we grow up on. Or are we just picking apart light hearted stories?
LikeLike
Ah, but fairly tales are not light hearted stories, they are parables meant to warn and shape behavior. If all of a little girls heros are powerless plot motivators that resolve nothing it make projecting into the fantasy less satisfying. I don’t see it as the source all social evil, but we can and should try harder.
LikeLike
Good point. Thanks for the blog
LikeLike
Thank you for taking the time to read and engage. It is genuinely appreciated.
LikeLike
Agreed. It’s interesting how different the original tale by Hans Christian Andersen is. I couldn’t believe my ears when I finally heard the original – so sad but much more meaningful. and much more realistic. I think it gives a much better message of self sacrifice and reality – coping wit stuff even when it feels impossible, and how things work together for good in the end.
LikeLike
Oh, please, please, please aim this fantastic vitriol at Aladdin, Transformers, and every Marvel comics rip-off to grace the big screen.
It’s easy: just target the ubiquitous premise that all problems are solved with massive force, unnecessary dick waving, and widespread damage and then build from there.
LikeLike
I am such an inveterate comic book geek it is difficult for me to properly critique the better marvel stuff. The bad (X-men 3, Wolverine Origins, Ghost Rider) just saddens me to the point of damp and useless wrath,
LikeLike
Great! Aaaaaand…..GO!”
PS: Damp wrath is nothing compared to diaper wrath.
LikeLike
Love this. You are very talented and insightful.
LikeLike
That is very generous. Much obliged.
LikeLike
This is an amazing interpretation of the actual lessons you get when you watch The little Mermaid as a child. I’ve watched all of the princess movies, so far I’ve always wondered what their REAL moral lessons are, since I can’t really find any without including love (considering the fact that the creators said it’s more suitable for children). I’m seventeen now and I have a more informed mind to discern things and what you’ve said in this article is really spot-on comical and, at the same time, insightful.
LikeLike
Good lord, you are way ahead of the game compared to me at 17. I was mostly reading old sugar packets and breaking into abandoned houses to find treasure. You are going to do well in this world.
LikeLike
You’re childhood seriously sounds more interesting than mine to be honest haha. By the way, hope your future uhmm daughter becomes as funny as you (and not as gullible as some little girls tend to be when it comes to watching princess movies, or any other “misleading” ones for that matter).
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Human Relationships.
LikeLike
Well that was a new take on my favourite childhood movie haha Very interesting and some relevant points… but I still love it 😉
LikeLike
As you should. Art doesn’t have to have a perfect message, it should be called out on it’s weaker moments but it should still be enjoyed.
LikeLike
Well said 🙂
LikeLike
I thoroughly enjoyed this. Just thought I’d point out a commonality in the Disney Princesses, they all have the gibson girl look. It’s to show girls that if you look like you’re on opiates, and distant mentally, guys will be sure to find you enchanting.
LikeLike
It’s the unavailability that’s intoxicating.
LikeLike
You should consider writing your own Disney tale, void of all the recurring misnomers that your abhorrent cynicism seems to have picked up on.
LikeLike
Just read game of Thrones. Arya Stark is the vengeful revanent that I hope my Daughter to be if I’m ever wronged.Also one of my favorite characters in all of fiction.
Additionally: The lessons I would impart in a such a work would likely be vastly more troubling for parents, if less misogynistic, than the current setup.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Yuanne Dynasty.
LikeLike
Way to ruin my favorite classic princess…. in a very good sarcastic-comedic way. You took the usual joke of fairy tale logic thing to the next level 🙂 keep ’em coming!
LikeLike
I’ll do my best to stomp out whatever remaining embers of childhood movie innocence that remains. I appreciate how sporting you’re being about the whole thing.
LikeLike
Yes, the Disney movies aren’t exactly the best places to get life lessons. At least Once Upon a Time tries and ultimately does a good job of showing that life is hard, love takes work, and yes, you have to have some common sense in order to make it in this world.
LikeLike
No argument here.
LikeLike
Well, let me know what you have to say about other Disney princess movies. There is never too little material to make into commentary with that genre.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on MISTUREBA – ARROZ, FEIJÃO E POLÍTICA.
LikeLike
You are my paradigm of hope in this unoriginal flophouse we call earth…well done my friend! I love new perspectives in life and this one is by far the most creative I have seen thus far in the WordPress Universe.
LikeLike
High praise indeed. I feel like I should have put on some pants before I replied to this one.
LikeLike
Not very many wordsmiths in the wide world today, It’s refreshing to find another human being with some command of the language and the balls to use it. Just found out about this site and I’m digging it. A majority of the blog pages are krap, do you have some favorites you can recommend?
Cheers my man
LikeLike
Reblogged this on "It's alright, Ma, it's life, and life only" A Blog site dedicated to those of us who use our skills to exchange heartache for humor,anxiety for drum beats, pain for paint and worry for fiction and commented:
Peep game….
LikeLike
Yes, yes, and yes! The Disney princess films are loaded with these messages. I am so glad to see this take on Disney making it outside academia to the blogosphere. Wish I had time to read the comments. People can be very protective of the American royals (ala Disney). Bravo to you!
LikeLike
This is about as far outside academia as one can get, so I suppose it’s a success. Bravo to everyone who wandered by the read it. Thank you.
LikeLike
*blogosphere
LikeLike
And all this is just for the Disney version. The original Hans Christian Anderson version, I found, to be far more farcically sad.
LikeLike
In fairness the sadness of the original was a legitimate reflection of the times.Akin the gangsta rap “expression of situation instead of glorifying it” corollary.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on yuliamarsupilami.
LikeLike
i see my childhood :(( hi guys! im new to this site so i hope u guys could help me out by viewing my page , tell me how to impeove it, and pls do follow me??
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Welcome To Awais Gillani Blog .
LikeLike
Hilarious, and absolutely correct. Well done, Sir.
LikeLike
Much appreciated.
LikeLike
What a wonderful interpretation. Loved the tongue in cheek narrative. Oh! Was there a moral of the story?
LikeLiked by 1 person
The moral I would have liked: No one else can make you a complete person. Find your intrinsic happiness/values before looking outside for who you need to be.
LikeLike
Very true. The pursuit of happiness should start from within.
LikeLike
A fresh perspective.
Some time back, I had made a rather crude attempt at lessons from Jeeves and Bertie Wooster. In case you like Wodehouse, you may check out the following post:
http://ashokbhatia.wordpress.com/2013/11/09/when-jeeevs-takes-charge.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Revisiting Sanity.
LikeLike
Awesome, thanks
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Majula of the mind and commented:
Pretty damn accurate analysis.
LikeLike
Pingback: 124/365 Today I … reblogged ‘Lessons from a Fantasy Princess: Snow White’ | Down My Front
Reblogged this on Perarl.
LikeLike
You Sir sound like the kind if father the world needs! Actions have consequences, and people have to live through them. Try teaching that to the majority of parents out there these days and you’ll have a revolt on your hands!
LikeLike
I’m afraid my children are still of the theoretical sort, as is my parenting ability, but the compliment is appreciated none the less.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Fa Fa Fa and commented:
Must Read!!
LikeLike
Very interesting
LikeLike
Reblogged this on joshylidavila95.
LikeLike
……….
LikeLike
Reblogged this on The Pursuit of Happiness.
LikeLike
Reblogged this on Ek Boond Ishq Unofficial.
LikeLike
my sisters dream
LikeLike